Thursday, 21 February 2019

Let me pitch something

By Chris Riddell
Here goes:

A setting guide and ruleset for sky ship operation and combat; to work in accordance with any adventuring ruleset you desire.

Adventure, obsession, madness, and death.

Think Moby Dick, Sunless Sea, and The Edge Chronicles.

Think Veins of the Earth but sky instead of rock; agoraphobia and horror vacui instead of claustrophobia.

The players are crewing a sky ship, a rickety death trap with a thousand essential mechanisms each of which can and will go wrong. This hunk of junk is the only thing standing between these brave or insane souls and the Long Drop.

They explore an impossible archipelago of broken rocks. Mountains and islands, forested and wild, slowly drifting in the wind, skirting the yawning void of the upper air: the Mountains Untethered. Above; the Verge, too close to the stars, where the air and reality itself are too thin, below, the Murk, where the only sky is the darkness of millions of tonnes of rock, where ramshackle towns squat in darkness in which washed-up and has-beens drink themselves to death, and where listless scavengers paddle the Murk Sea for the wreckage of those who made the Long Drop.

The Mountains are a region uncharted and unchartable, filled with creatures strange and people yet stranger - certainly the natives and creatures of this odd land are bizarre, but perhaps moreso are the ones who come here voluntarily.

Cloudpiercers they are called: idealist settlers building utopia, discontent colonists hatching secession, treasure-hunters seeking their fortune, merchants want trade routs and to fatten their wallets, pirates slit throats and loot bodies, stormhunters and galechasers hunt in the shrieking air, flotillas of desperate men and the navy of empire - all fighting it out in the open skies.

Wild-eyed and manic to a man, they brave the abyss below and the void above for their particular obsession, their private insane drive - but all of them desire to make a mark on the maddeningly empty air before they too go to their Long Drop.


Monday, 18 February 2019

Name Change

I changed the blog name. It's now Sword of Mass Destruction.

It used to be Pammachon Sword.

The Pammachon Sword is something from Caráxe that blew up the Northern Invader. That land now lies on the bottom of the Searing Deep.

It was a Sword of Mass Destruction.

Well, then just say that, you idiot! At least that's got some punch to it.

What if magic items can't be identified?

By Mike Vivisector
The setup

Many OSR systems don't have perception rolls.

"Figure it out yourself!" they say, after telling you to get of their lawn. "Just say where you look or what you're touching, and I'll tell you if you find anything!"

Now, I think this is a good system. A perception roll is a boring way to resolve searching. It removes agency from the player and makes something that could make the situation very tactile and real into something abstract and gamey.

The logical end point of the perception roll is a game in which player input is completely superfluous and stats determine everything. And that isn't fun. So, some say, no perception rolls.

So, given that many people think that way, why do we still roll arcane knowledge or intelligence to identify magic items?

The problem
"This is a mysterious ring; ancient, covered in runes." 
"I want to examine it, see if it's magic." 
"After spending some minutes sniffing, touching, and examining the thing, you can safely say it exudes an aura of magic. It makes your hairs stand on end. Sparks jump between the metal and your fingers." 
"I want to figure out what kind." 
"Okay, roll an intelligence check." 
"Made it." 
"Yeah it's a ring that gives you +3 to lockpicking."

That's boring. Yes, also because I used a boring magic item in that example. But not only is it boring, it is soooo gamey.

An aside:
DnD uses numbers because it wants to quantify and make concrete certain variables. But just as "16 Strength" doesn't mean anything in the world of the fiction, so do the numbers on magic not mean anything. Or the words fire damage.

Numbers are an unelegant crutch; a necessary evil. They should be avoided in descriptive language if possible. They break the fiction.

A solution

When running the Tomb of the Serpent Kings, my players tried on the Ring of Eyesight that makes a player's eye go hard as glass and pop out of his socket, and the ring which turns a finger into a two-pronged poison dagger. They loved it and were horrified at the same time. They laughed and were fascinated and audibly disgusted.

They also figured out some magic effects by running intelligence checks. They went "oh, that's cool I guess."

Don't allow your players to identify magic items. Yeah, not even wizards. Let them detect if it is magical. Then, if they succeed what would otherwise be an identifying roll, let them find out only how the magic works. Is it an ongoing power? Or is it a power that can be released? Is it an on-target magic? A self spell? Or a latent power, like a buff? Tell them what they perceive, so that they at least have some notion of how to activate the power. Using an unknown power is fun; clicking all the pixels in order to find the one that lets you proceed isn't.

Then tell them the associations they pick up: "You can tell that it's something to do with throwing." "You think the magic has something to do with food." "You think the magic is dangerous." "You feel an immense sorrow", "You smell burning". Roll a 1d6 for associations. There's a 1 in 6 chance the associations are totally wrong.

Then, let them find out the effects by experimentation. Because that's fun and unpredictable. Furthermore, it keeps magic strange and potentially dangerous.

And it saves you form saying the words "it gives a d6 bonus" or something equally magic-breaking. Just tell them, when they use it, to roll an extra d6. Don't tell them why. Don't break the magic. Remove the extra die when they remove the magic item. But never acknowledge that the object is responsible for the d6. That makes it knowable, concrete, gamey. As long as you never name the effects in concrete, numbery ways, it might still have other secrets to reveal and as such, it might remain mysterious.

I will be playtesting this idea.

21 Minor Spirits your players might run into

Spirits live everywhere.

They're not like spells. Spells are from another realm, scintillating with power; these things were just born in the mud and the dirt and the trash. They arise out of the structures of their place the way human minds arise out of the structure of the brain.

Spirits are magical and mysterious. Most of them come out at night, and they possess an odd ability to go unnoticed even when taking shape. They vanish if spooked or attacked, and might leave you with curses. They probably can talk, but just don't.
A bridge spirit hiding in the water. By Theodor Kittelsen.
SPIRIT HP 1 Def 0 Movement 13 (but can vanish at will) Attack 0 Intelligence 10 Reaction 10 Morale 0. Cannot be hurt by physical weaponry. If a spirit is destroyed with magic, it simply reforms in 1d6 days unless it is driven away by dispelling, or if the place it is bound to is destroyed.

They're like gods, but really puny. Each well spirit is THE well spirit, if you catch my drift. They're both less and more than individuals. They're less in that they are more like natural things, such as rainbows or earthquakes or trees, but more in that they are multiple fragments of the *concept* of the thing they are bound to, such as home. They aren't just a creature tied to a place or object. They *are* the very notion of "home" themselves.

All of them are shapeshifters and not bound to a physical form, but one shape is the default one, their "chosen" shape. But they might as well be that passerby that asked you that really strange question.



Sunday, 17 February 2019

Tomb of the Serpent Kings write-up 1

So I've got a bit of a confession to make.

I've never DM'ed before.

I know!

And I've only played Dungeons and Dragons for what must be less than 15 sessions, too. That was 5th edition, and the people I ways playing with cared about a lot of stuff I didn't care about (lots of combat and very little thinking or discovering). So what am I doing writing a blog? Well, in my defense, this blog is mostly for me; and secondly, you're in no way obligated to read.

Anyway, I DM'ed Tomb of the Serpent Kings yesterday, for five players, four of which had never played a table-top RPG before. They were all friends and family - one of them was my mom.

I thought this dungeon would absolutely destroy them.

So far they're all fine.

So yeah.

I learned many things. I learned that a DM must keep track of *a lot* of things. I learned that you shouldn't go too easy on players. I learned much more. Here's a write-up.

Thursday, 7 February 2019

I Loathe Elves



Elves are just the worst.

And I'm not blaming the big grandad here. Tolkien's elves are not "elves" as trope. In Tolkien's world,
  • elves don't have pointy ears
  • elves and humans are apparently of same appearance; people and elves get mixed up (eyes and voice might give it away)
  • elves don't have alien-level tech. They wear mail like everybody else.
  • elves and humans are not really different species as much as they are different spiritualities, or something. You can see this in Elrond and his brother both being half-human, half-elf; and they get to pick which they want to be.
So there's a lot with Tolkien's elves that's less elvish than the trope they codified.

Everything I loathe about elves is a later invention - that sterile, boring, emotionless, technically superior and more skilled but in motivation still exceedingly human. It's a regular person, but more capable. Not wiser. That's mary sue. They're a nation of mary sues. Now if they had a totally different system of value or way of experiencing life - that would be interesting, right??? But no. They're people but better in everything except where it counts.

This has been reacted to by people like Scrap Princess and Arnold K of Goblin Punch. Their elves are terrifying because they are physically superior to humans but mentally and spiritually in no way wiser or more enlightened. They're scary; they're psycho's because of their superiority.

Of course elves are also storystelling shorthand. Elves are elegant; bam, done. Are brabbo's elegant? I don't know, because I have no frame of reference. That's an important point, but I LOATHE ELVES.

So there's no elves in Circassa. There's goblins - they're good guys now - there's orcs. There's fairies and spirits. No elves. The ancient rulers of Tel Ammon might have been elves. The scary kind. The imperial kind. The superior kind. The psycho kind.

But playable elves and half-elves? No. Cause an actual elf would not go adventuring. It would sit around moping and meditating on a higher plane of spiritual development, or it would be a terrifiying force of conquest. It would not adventure. Takes me out of every game.

The Bladeless Blade of Kammorachû


TL;DR: It's a blade that works as a spell. Any spell.

In the north the legends of the ancient kingdom of Tel Ammon are still whispered rather than spoken aloud, and never at night. Their enormous ruins, tombs, and broken statues still dot the north, and the darkness pooling in those tombs and in the shadows of those ruins is unquiet.

Still more is whispered of the Ammon mage Kammorachû, a bitter and black-hearted man, who deep in his cavernous lair beneath the city of Akh-Ammon forged the Bladeless Blade.

The Bladeless Blade, has, as the name tells, no blade; it is hilt only. Just a hilt. Useless. But for the gifted, those in the know, the Bladeless Blade is also a cage. It can capture spirits. It can capture spells.

When Kammorachû wielded it in battle against the southern birdmen the blade sizzled and thundered; some spells of water and lightning where intertwined there. It soaked and electrocuted the enemy simultaneously.
When the foul mage wielded it during the Ammon Kinstrife it sputtered and flared like oily flame. Fire and grease was on it. It set the enemy in flame as if they had been drenched in lamp oil.
When he cut off the head of the leader of the third slave rebellion, he had no spell on the blade at all. It is said that the Bladeless Blade caught the soul of the slave leader; sucked it right out of his heart, and used it as blade and that afterwards, the invisible blade screamed in anguish as it cut down its former comrades.
He wielded it with a spell of Cutting against the mountain hordes. Its blade was invisible but cut through sword, armour, and flesh as if it was nothing.

Rumour has it the dark one, Kammorachû, assassinated his own king and usurped the throne with the Bladeless Blade, using some vile curse set in the blade. He cut the king by stealth; the blade was mere hilt, after all, and easy to conceal. The curse could not be seen, nor did the king feel anything when he was cut; but it bit deep, and worked its way inside the king for 50 years, while Kammorachû waited patiently, till at last he died of some sudden illness - which the race of Ammon does not suffer. The Fifty Year Sword it is also called because of this. Deep its bite can be, but slow the blood to run...


Yeah it's a hilt you can put a spell on and I mean any spell. This is gonna fuck your game up.

The antimander: will eat your torch right as you need it

Monster: the antimander  HD : 3 (14 HP) Appearance : big slimy salamander, cute shiny eyes Voice : guttural screeches, short broken sentence...